Recent changes in real estate regulations that took effect on August 17, 2024, have brought significant shifts in how real estate transactions are conducted. These new rules, which include the elimination of MLS (Multiple Listing Service) offers of compensation and a requirement for written agreements with buyers, are reshaping the home market for both buyers and sellers.
Traditionally, when someone bought a home, they didn’t have to pay their real estate agent directly. Instead, the seller of the home would cover the commission fees for both the buyer’s agent and the seller’s agent. These fees are typically around 5% to 6% of the home’s sale price. For example, if a home is sold for $450,000 the seller would end up paying about $27,000 in commission fees. Many experts believe that these commission fees are built into the home’s asking price, which means that home prices are slightly higher to account for these costs.
What Do These Changes Mean?
For Sellers:
Sellers now face a change in how they offer compensation to agents who represent buyers. Previously, sellers could advertise compensation offers directly on MLS platforms, a standard practice that provided clarity and transparency. Under the new rules, sellers can still choose to offer compensation, but they can no longer advertise these offers via the MLS. This change means sellers and their agents must discuss compensation agreements privately, outside of the MLS listings. This could lead to more direct negotiations and possibly more strategic discussions about how much compensation to offer buyer agents. Sellers considering selling their home should consult with their real estate agent to understand how these changes might affect their transactions and to explore the best strategies moving forward.
For Buyers:
The new regulations significantly impact buyers as well. Buyers who wish to tour properties now have three distinct options, each with different implications for their relationship with real estate agents:
- Buyer Agency Agreement: This option establishes a formal client relationship between the buyer and the agent. The agent represents the buyer’s interests throughout the transaction, providing comprehensive advice, information, and negotiation services. This agreement offers the most protection and support for buyers but typically involves a commitment to work exclusively with that agent.
- Pre-Agency Agreement: This temporary arrangement allows buyers to tour a property without committing to a full agency agreement. The agent does not represent either party during the showing and cannot provide advice or negotiate on behalf of the buyer. However, the form does include a section where compensation to the agent showing the home can be specified.
- Disclosure to Customer: Under this arrangement, the agent is representing the seller, and the buyer is treated as a customer rather than a client. The agent’s duties to the buyer are limited, focusing primarily on honesty and disclosure of material facts. This option offers the least protection to buyers and limits the agent’s ability to advocate on their behalf.
Why These New Rules?
The new real estate regulations are a response to legal challenges and lawsuits. The changes were prompted by a series of high-profile class-action lawsuits against the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and several major real estate firms. These lawsuits allege that the traditional practice of offering buyer agent commissions through the MLS (Multiple Listing Service) has led to inflated costs for consumers and reduced competition in the market.
Background on the Lawsuit and Its Impact
The lawsuits, such as those filed in Missouri (the Sitzer/Burnett case) and Illinois (the Moehrl case), argue that the practice of requiring sellers to offer compensation to buyer agents through the MLS artificially inflates commissions. The plaintiffs claim this system violates antitrust laws because it discourages competition and keeps commissions high, costing consumers billions of dollars annually. They argue that these practices are outdated and that, in a more competitive and transparent market, buyer agents would negotiate their compensation directly with their clients, rather than relying on sellers to offer these commissions.
How the Lawsuit Led to New Regulations
As a result of these lawsuits, real estate organizations, including the NAR, have been forced to reconsider their policies and practices to avoid further legal action and to comply with potential new regulatory requirements. To address these concerns and mitigate legal risks, the NAR and other industry players have implemented changes, such as:
- Eliminating MLS Offers of Compensation: To reduce the appearance of anti-competitive behavior, the new rules no longer allow the direct advertising of compensation offers to buyer agents on MLS platforms. This shift aims to foster a more competitive environment where commissions are negotiated directly between buyers and their agents.
- Requiring Written Agreements with Buyers: By requiring written agreements when working with buyers, the new regulations promote transparency and ensure that buyers understand the terms of their engagement with real estate agents. This change helps clarify the roles and responsibilities of agents and prevents misunderstandings that could lead to further legal disputes.
These regulatory changes represent a significant shift in the real estate industry, moving away from practices that have been standard for decades. For both buyers and sellers, this means navigating a more complex landscape where direct negotiation and clear agreements are essential. Real estate agents and prospective buyers and sellers may encounter a more complex system that they are use to.
